US5878233A
Expired / Lapsed
US
⏱️ 0.0 years remaining
System, method, and computer program product for reviewing and creating advisories for data located on a content server
Assignee: Activision Publishing Inc
•
Filing: 1995-08-07
•
Granted: 1999-03-02
•
Expires: 2015-08-07
Abstract
Abstract A system and method which can efficiently develop new and revised advisories on content loaded (or available to be loaded) by a client from a content server via a protocol between the client and any number of advisory servers that maintain "ratings" knowledge bases. In one example, the advisory servers can be any number of independent non-co-located or combined servers in the World Wide Web. Alternatively, the functions of the advisory server can be integrated with the functions of the content server. Advisories can be efficiently developed based on rational factors, including: suggestions from users of an advisory service; as yet unrated content for which queries are being received; and requests from providers of new and revised primary content. Embodiments of the operation of an advisory server and reviewer's tool are described wherein content which clients are sending queries about, but which have not yet been reviewed, (i.e., not stored in an advisories database) are placed on a to-be-reviewed queue for processing by the reviewer's tool. New and revised advisories may also be created as a result of suggested advisories submitted from clients. New and revised advisories may further be created as a result of new or revised content for which a primary publisher desires (and may wish to pay for) an advisory.
Inventors
- 👤 Robert Jeffrey Schloss
Bibliographic Details
Application Number
—
Jurisdiction
US
Data Source
google_patents
Last Synchronized
2026-10-27 20:21
CPC Classifications
G; G06; G06Q; G06Q20/00; G06Q20/08; G06Q20/10; Y; Y10; Y10S; Y10S707/00; Y10S707/99931; Y10S707/99939
Claims Analysis
Total Claims: 54
Claim 1
Independent Claim
249 words
A method of creating and processing characterization data associated with content data in a distributed data communication system of a type wherein communication between a content requestor and a first content server occurs over a first communication link, and wherein said content requestor under control of user input communicates a data request signal to said first content server over said first communication link, and wherein said first content server, upon receiving said data request signal, communicates said content data to said content requestor according to said data request signal, comprising the steps of: setting said content requestor in an advisory mode wherein said content requestor communicates portions of said data request signal to a first advisory server over a second communication link different from said first communication link, and wherein said first advisory server is remote from said first content server; upon receipt of said portions of said data request signal by said first advisory server, searching a data base coupled to said first advisory server for characterization data linked to said portions of said data request signal; in the event said searching for said characterization data linked to said portions of said data request signal is unsuccessful, storing said portions of said data request signal in a review queue associated with said advisory server; and retrieving said portions of said data request signal stored in said review queue and creating and storing said characterization data linked to said portions of said data request signal in said data base.
Claim 2
Independent Claim
249 words
A method of creating and processing characterization data associated with content data in a distributed data communication system of a type wherein communication between a content requestor and a first content server occurs over a first communication link, and wherein said content requestor under control of user input communicates a data request signal to said first content server over said first communication link, and wherein said first content server, upon receiving said data request signal, communicates said content data to said content requestor according to said data request signal, comprising the steps of: setting said content requestor in an advisory mode wherein said content requestor communicates portions of said data request signal to a first advisory server over a second communication link different from said first communication link, and wherein said first advisory server is remote from said first content server; upon receipt of said portions of said data request signal by said first advisory server, searching a data base coupled to said first advisory server for characterization data linked to said portions of said data request signal; in the event said searching for said characterization data linked to said portions of said data request signal is unsuccessful, storing said portions of said data request signal in a review queue associated with said advisory server; and retrieving said portions of said data request signal stored in said review queue and creating and storing said characterization data linked to said portions of said data request signal in said data base.
Claim 3
Dependent Claim
22 words
The method of claim 1 wherein said retrieving step is performed asynchronously to said storing said portions of said data request signal.
Claim 4
Dependent Claim
87 words
The method of claim 1, wherein said step of retrieving said portions of said data request signal comprises the step of: determining that the content data associated with said portions of said data request signal are not within the scope of said first advisory server; and storing said portions of said data request signal on an ignore queue coupled to said first advisory server wherein said ignore queue includes a list of said portions of said data request signal for which characterization data should not be generated.
Claim 5
Dependent Claim
31 words
The method of claim 3, wherein said searching a data base comprises the step of: searching for and identifying said portions of said data request signal stored on said ignore queue.
Claim 6
Dependent Claim
56 words
The method of claim 1 wherein said step of creating and storing said characterization data linked to said portions of said data request signal in said data base comprises the step of: identifying and adding said characterization data linked to said portions of said data request signal requiring periodic revision-review queue coupled to said advisory server.
Claim 7
Dependent Claim
88 words
The method of claim 1 wherein said searching for said characterization data linked to said portions of said data request signal is unsuccessful, comprises the steps of: generating and communicating a data-not-found-response to said content requestor; and upon receipt of said portions of said data-not-found-response, said content requestor, in said advisory mode, creating and communicating a suggested characterization data to a suggested-queue coupled to said advisory server wherein said suggested characterization data includes data identifying said content requestor as well as said portions of said data request signal.
Claim 8
Dependent Claim
60 words
The method of claim 6, further comprises the step of: controlling said first advisory server to retrieve said suggested characterization data from said suggested queue; and in the event said suggested characterization data is accepted, storing in said data base said suggested characterization data as characterization data linked to said portions of said data request signal in said data base.
Claim 9
Dependent Claim
44 words
The method of claim 7, wherein said controlling said first advisory server to retrieve said suggested characterization data from said suggested queue further comprises the step of: modifying said suggested characterization data prior to said storing said suggested characterization data in said data base.
Claim 10
Dependent Claim
35 words
The method of claim 7, wherein said controlling said first advisory server to retrieve said suggested characterization data from said suggested queue further comprises the step of: displaying said suggested characterization data on a display.
Claim 11
Dependent Claim
48 words
The method of claim 7, wherein said controlling said first advisory server to retrieve said suggested characterization data from said suggested queue further comprises the step of: prioritizing said suggested queue as a function of the accept/reject ratio for prior suggested characterization data communicated from said content requestor.
Claim 12
Dependent Claim
39 words
The method of claim 7, when said suggested characterization data is accepted, further comprising the step of: controlling said advisory server to generate a credit request signal responsive to said storing said suggested characterization data in said data base.
Claim 13
Dependent Claim
22 words
The method of claim 1, wherein said characterization data comprises a return code, a short string field, and a long string field.
Claim 14
Independent Claim
214 words
A method of creating and revising characterization data associated with content data in a distributed data communication system of a type wherein communication between a content requestor and a first content server occurs over a first communication link, and wherein said content requestor under control of user input communicates a data request signal to said first content server over said first communication link, and wherein said first content server, upon receiving said data request signal, communicates said content data to sad content requestor according to said data request signal, comprising the steps of: setting a characterization requestor associated with said first content server in an advisory mode wherein said characterization requestor communicates a request-for-review signal including portions of said data request signal, and an identification signal to a first advisory server over a second communication link different from said first communication link, wherein said first advisory server is remote form said first content server; upon receipt of said portions of said request-for-review signal by said first advisory server, storing said request-for-review signal in a review queue coupled to said first advisory server; and retrieving said portions of said request-for-review signal stored in said review queue and creating and storing in said data base characterization data linked to said portions of said data request signal.
Claim 15
Independent Claim
214 words
A method of creating and revising characterization data associated with content data in a distributed data communication system of a type wherein communication between a content requestor and a first content server occurs over a first communication link, and wherein said content requestor under control of user input communicates a data request signal to said first content server over said first communication link, and wherein said first content server, upon receiving said data request signal, communicates said content data to sad content requestor according to said data request signal, comprising the steps of: setting a characterization requestor associated with said first content server in an advisory mode wherein said characterization requestor communicates a request-for-review signal including portions of said data request signal, and an identification signal to a first advisory server over a second communication link different from said first communication link, wherein said first advisory server is remote form said first content server; upon receipt of said portions of said request-for-review signal by said first advisory server, storing said request-for-review signal in a review queue coupled to said first advisory server; and retrieving said portions of said request-for-review signal stored in said review queue and creating and storing in said data base characterization data linked to said portions of said data request signal.
Claim 16
Dependent Claim
75 words
The method of claim 13 wherein said step of creating and storing in said data base said characterization data linked to said portions of said data request signal comprises the step of: communicating a payment-request signal to said characterization requestor over said second communication link, wherein said payment-request signal includes the monetary charge incurred for said creating and storing in said data base said characterization data linked to said portions of said data request signal.
Claim 17
Independent Claim
274 words
A system for creating and processing characterization data associated with content data in a distributed data communication system of a type wherein communication between a content requestor and a first content server occurs over a first communication link, and wherein said content requestor under control of user input communicates a data request signal to said first content server over said first communication link, and wherein said first content server, upon receiving said data request signal, communicates said content data to said content requestor according to said data request signal, comprising: a first advisory server coupled to said content requestor over a second communication link different from said first communication link wherein said first advisory server is remote from said first content server; a data base coupled to said first advisory server, said data base including characterization data which is linked to said portions of said data request signal; setting means for setting said content requestor in an advisory mode wherein said content requestor communicates portions of said data request signal to said first advisory server over said second communication link; searching means for searching said data base for said data base for said characterization data, responsive to receipt of said portions of said data request signal by said first advisory server; a review queue associated with said advisory server for storing said portions of said data request signal associated with said advisory server, in the event said searching for said characterization data is unsuccessful; retrieving means for retrieving said portions of said data request signal stored in said review queue; and creating means for creating and storing said characterization data in said data base.
Claim 18
Independent Claim
274 words
A system for creating and processing characterization data associated with content data in a distributed data communication system of a type wherein communication between a content requestor and a first content server occurs over a first communication link, and wherein said content requestor under control of user input communicates a data request signal to said first content server over said first communication link, and wherein said first content server, upon receiving said data request signal, communicates said content data to said content requestor according to said data request signal, comprising: a first advisory server coupled to said content requestor over a second communication link different from said first communication link wherein said first advisory server is remote from said first content server; a data base coupled to said first advisory server, said data base including characterization data which is linked to said portions of said data request signal; setting means for setting said content requestor in an advisory mode wherein said content requestor communicates portions of said data request signal to said first advisory server over said second communication link; searching means for searching said data base for said data base for said characterization data, responsive to receipt of said portions of said data request signal by said first advisory server; a review queue associated with said advisory server for storing said portions of said data request signal associated with said advisory server, in the event said searching for said characterization data is unsuccessful; retrieving means for retrieving said portions of said data request signal stored in said review queue; and creating means for creating and storing said characterization data in said data base.
Claim 19
Dependent Claim
16 words
The system of claim 15 wherein said retrieving means is performed asynchronously to said storing means.
Claim 20
Dependent Claim
81 words
The system of claim 15, wherein said retrieving means further comprises: in the event that the content data associated with said portions of said data request signal are not within the scope of said first advisory server, storing means for storing said portions of said data request signal on an ignore queue coupled to said first advisory server wherein said ignore queue includes a list of said portions of said data request signal for which characterization data should not be generated.
Claim 21
Dependent Claim
29 words
The system of claim 17, wherein said searching means further comprises: searching means for searching and identifying said portions of said data request signal stored on said ignore queue.
Claim 22
Dependent Claim
32 words
The system of claim 15 wherein said creating means further comprises: identifying means for identifying and adding said characterization data requiring periodic revision to a periodic-review queue coupled to said advisory server.
Claim 23
Dependent Claim
99 words
The system of claim 15 wherein said searching means is unsuccessful, further comprising: communicating means for generating and communicating a data-not-found-response to said content requestor; and data characterizer means for creating and communicating a suggested characterization data from said content requestor in said advisory mode to a suggested-queue coupled to said advisory server wherein said suggested characterization data includes data identifying said content requestor as well as said portions of said data request signal, responsive to the receipt of said portions of said data-not-found-response by said content requestor wherein said data characterization means is coupled to said content requestor.
Claim 24
Dependent Claim
47 words
The system of claim 20, further comprising: controlling means for controlling said first advisory server to retrieve said suggested characterization data from said suggested queue; and in the event said suggested characterization data is accepted, storing means for storing said suggested characterization data in said data base.
Claim 25
Dependent Claim
31 words
The system of claim 21, wherein said controlling means further comprises: modifying means for modifying said suggested characterization data prior to said storing said suggested characterization data in said data base.
Claim 26
Dependent Claim
22 words
The system of claim 21, wherein said controlling means further comprises: displaying means for displaying said suggested characterization data on a display.
Claim 27
Dependent Claim
48 words
The system of claim 21, wherein said controlling said first advisory server to retrieve said suggested characterization data from said suggested queue further comprises: prioritizing means for prioritizing said suggested queue as a function of the accept/reject ratio for prior suggested characterization data communicated from said content requestor.
Claim 28
Dependent Claim
40 words
The system of claim 21, wherein said suggested characterization data is accepted, further comprising: credit generating means for controlling said advisory server to generate a credit request signal responsive to said storing said suggested characterization data in said data base.
Claim 29
Dependent Claim
22 words
The system of claim 15, wherein said characterization data comprises a return code, a short string field, and a long string filed.
Claim 30
Independent Claim
277 words
A system of creating and revising characterization data associated with content data in a distributed data communication system of a type wherein communication between a content requestor and a first content server occurs over a first communication link, and wherein said content requestor under control of user input communicates a data request signal to said first content server over said first communication link, and wherein said first content server, upon receiving said data request signal, communicates said content data to said content requestor according to said data request signal, comprising: a first advisory server coupled to said content requestor over a second communication link different from said first communication link wherein said first advisory server is remote from said first content server; a data base coupled to said first advisory server, said data base including characterization data which is linked to said portions of said data request signal; a characterization requestor coupled to said first advisory server over a second communication link different from said first communication link, wherein said first advisory server is remote from said first content server; setting means for setting said characterization requestor in an advisory mode wherein said characterization requestor communicates a request-for-review signal including portions of said data request signal, and a requester-identification signal to said first advisory server; a review queue coupled to said first advisory server, for storing said request-for-review signal, responsive to receipt of said portions of said request-for-review signal by said first advisory server; retrieving means for retrieving said portions of said request-for-review signal stored in said review queue; and creating means for creating and storing in said data base characterization data associated with said content data.
Claim 31
Independent Claim
277 words
A system of creating and revising characterization data associated with content data in a distributed data communication system of a type wherein communication between a content requestor and a first content server occurs over a first communication link, and wherein said content requestor under control of user input communicates a data request signal to said first content server over said first communication link, and wherein said first content server, upon receiving said data request signal, communicates said content data to said content requestor according to said data request signal, comprising: a first advisory server coupled to said content requestor over a second communication link different from said first communication link wherein said first advisory server is remote from said first content server; a data base coupled to said first advisory server, said data base including characterization data which is linked to said portions of said data request signal; a characterization requestor coupled to said first advisory server over a second communication link different from said first communication link, wherein said first advisory server is remote from said first content server; setting means for setting said characterization requestor in an advisory mode wherein said characterization requestor communicates a request-for-review signal including portions of said data request signal, and a requester-identification signal to said first advisory server; a review queue coupled to said first advisory server, for storing said request-for-review signal, responsive to receipt of said portions of said request-for-review signal by said first advisory server; retrieving means for retrieving said portions of said request-for-review signal stored in said review queue; and creating means for creating and storing in said data base characterization data associated with said content data.
Claim 32
Dependent Claim
56 words
The system of claim 27, wherein said request-for-review-signal includes a billing-info signal and wherein said creating means further comprises: payment-request means for communicating a payment-request signal to said characterization requestor over said second communication link, wherein said payment-request signal includes the monetary charge incurred for said creating and storing in said data base said characterization data.
Claim 33
Independent Claim
195 words
A method of creating and processing characterization data associated with content data in a distributed data communication system of a type wherein communication between a content requestor and a first content server occurs over a first communication link, and wherein said content requestor under control of user input communicates a data request signal to said first content server over said first communication link, and wherein said first content server, upon receiving said data request signal, communicates said content data to said content requestor according to said data request signal, said method comprising the steps of: receiving portions of said data request signal; searching a data base for characterization data linked to said portions of said data request signal, in response to said receiving step; in the event said searching for said characterization data linked to said portions of said data request signal is unsuccessful, storing said portions of said data request signal in a review queue associated with said advisory server; and retrieving said portions of said data request signal stored in said review queue and creating and storing said characterization data linked to said portions of said data request signal in said data base.
Claim 34
Independent Claim
195 words
A method of creating and processing characterization data associated with content data in a distributed data communication system of a type wherein communication between a content requestor and a first content server occurs over a first communication link, and wherein said content requestor under control of user input communicates a data request signal to said first content server over said first communication link, and wherein said first content server, upon receiving said data request signal, communicates said content data to said content requestor according to said data request signal, said method comprising the steps of: receiving portions of said data request signal; searching a data base for characterization data linked to said portions of said data request signal, in response to said receiving step; in the event said searching for said characterization data linked to said portions of said data request signal is unsuccessful, storing said portions of said data request signal in a review queue associated with said advisory server; and retrieving said portions of said data request signal stored in said review queue and creating and storing said characterization data linked to said portions of said data request signal in said data base.
Claim 35
Dependent Claim
57 words
The method of claim 29, further comprising the step of: setting said content requestor in an advisory mode; said content requestor communicating said portions of said data request signal to a first advisory server over a second communication link different from said first communication link; wherein said first advisory server is remote from said first content server.
Claim 36
Dependent Claim
22 words
The method of claim 29 wherein said retrieving step is performed asynchronously to said storing said portions of said data request signal.
Claim 37
Dependent Claim
87 words
The method of claim 29, wherein said step of retrieving said portions of said data request signal comprises the steps of: determining that the content data associated with said portions of said data request signal are not within the scope of said first advisory server; and storing said portions of said data request signal on an ignore queue coupled to said first advisory server wherein said ignore queue includes a list of said portions of said data request signal for which characterization data should not be generated.
Claim 38
Dependent Claim
31 words
The method of claim 32, wherein said searching a data base comprises the steps of searching for and identifying said portions of said data request signal stored on said ignore queue.
Claim 39
Dependent Claim
59 words
The method of claim 29 wherein said step of creating and storing said characterization data linked to said portions of said data request signal in said data base comprises the step of identifying and adding said characterization data linked to said portions of said data request signal requiring periodic revision to a periodic-review queue coupled to said advisory server.
Claim 40
Dependent Claim
22 words
The method of claim 29, wherein said characterization data comprises a return code, a short string field, and a long string field.
Claim 41
Dependent Claim
76 words
The method of claim 29, wherein said searching for said characterization data linked to said portions of said data request signal is unsuccessful, comprises the steps of: generating and communicating a data-not-found-response to said content requestor; and upon receipt of said data-not-found-response, said content requestor creating and communicating a suggested characterization data to a suggested-queue, wherein said suggested characterization data includes data identifying said content requestor as well as said portions of said data request signal.
Claim 42
Dependent Claim
46 words
The method of claim 36, further comprises the steps of: retrieving said suggested characterization data from said suggested queue; and accepting and storing said suggested characterization in said data base as characterization data linked to said portions of said data request signal in said data base.
Claim 43
Dependent Claim
87 words
The method of claim 36, further comprising the steps of: setting said content requestor in an advisory mode; said content requestor communicating said portions of said data request signal to a first advisory server over a second communication link different from said first communication link; wherein said first advisory server is remote from said first content server; wherein said data-not found response is communicated by said advisory server to said content requester in said advisory mode and wherein said suggested queue is coupled to said advisory server.
Claim 44
Dependent Claim
40 words
The method of claim 37, wherein said step of retrieving said suggested characterization data from said suggested queue further comprises the step of modifying said suggested characterization data prior to said storing said suggested characterization data in said data base.
Claim 45
Dependent Claim
31 words
The method of claim 37, wherein said step of retrieving said suggested characterization data from said suggested queue further comprises the step of displaying said suggested characterization data on a display.
Claim 46
Dependent Claim
44 words
The method of claim 37, wherein said step of retrieving said suggested characterization data from said suggested queue further comprises the step of prioritizing said suggested queue as a function of the accept/reject ratio for prior suggested characterization data communicated from said content requestor.
Claim 47
Dependent Claim
43 words
The method of claim 37, wherein said steps of accepting and storing said suggested characterization data further comprises the step of controlling said advisory server to generate a credit request signal responsive to said storing said suggested characterization data in said data base.
Claim 48
Independent Claim
150 words
A method of creating and revising characterization data associated with content data in a distributed data communication system of a type wherein communication between a content requestor and a content server occurs over a first communication link, and wherein said content requestor under control of user input communicates a data request signal to said content server over said first communication link, and wherein said content server, upon receiving said data request signal, communicates said content data to said content requestor according to said data request signal, comprising the steps of: receiving a request-for-review signal including portions of said data request signal and an identification signal; upon receipt of said portions of said request-for-review signal, storing said request-for-review signal in a review queue; and retrieving said portions of said request-for-review signal stored in said review queue and creating and storing characterization data linked to said portions of said data request signal.
Claim 49
Independent Claim
150 words
A method of creating and revising characterization data associated with content data in a distributed data communication system of a type wherein communication between a content requestor and a content server occurs over a first communication link, and wherein said content requestor under control of user input communicates a data request signal to said content server over said first communication link, and wherein said content server, upon receiving said data request signal, communicates said content data to said content requestor according to said data request signal, comprising the steps of: receiving a request-for-review signal including portions of said data request signal and an identification signal; upon receipt of said portions of said request-for-review signal, storing said request-for-review signal in a review queue; and retrieving said portions of said request-for-review signal stored in said review queue and creating and storing characterization data linked to said portions of said data request signal.
Claim 50
Dependent Claim
48 words
The method of claim 43, further comprising the steps of: setting a characterization requestor associated with said content server in an advisory mode; and communicating said request-for-review signal over a second communication link, different from said first communication link, to an advisory server remote from said content server.
Claim 51
Dependent Claim
75 words
The method of claim 44, wherein said step of creating and storing in said data base said characterization data linked to said portions of said data request signal comprises the step of: communicating a payment-request signal to said characterization requestor over said second communication link, wherein said payment-request signal includes the monetary charge incurred for said creating and storing in said data base said characterization data linked to said portions of said data request signal.
Claim 52
Independent Claim
189 words
A system for creating and processing characterization data associated with content data in a distributed data communication system of a type wherein communication between a content requestor and a content server occurs over a first communication link, and wherein said content requestor under control of user input communicates a data request signal to said content server over said first communication link, and wherein said content server, upon receiving said data request signal, communicates said content data to said content requestor according to said data request signal, comprising: a data base including characterization data which is linked to said portions of said data request signal; searching means for searching said data base for said characterization data, responsive to receipt of said portions of said data request signal; a review queue for storing said portions of said data request signal, in the event said searching for said characterization data is unsuccessful; retrieving means for retrieving said portions of said data request signal stored in said review queue; and creating means for creating and storing in said data base characterization data associated with said data request signal, in response to said retrieving.
Claim 53
Independent Claim
189 words
A system for creating and processing characterization data associated with content data in a distributed data communication system of a type wherein communication between a content requestor and a content server occurs over a first communication link, and wherein said content requestor under control of user input communicates a data request signal to said content server over said first communication link, and wherein said content server, upon receiving said data request signal, communicates said content data to said content requestor according to said data request signal, comprising: a data base including characterization data which is linked to said portions of said data request signal; searching means for searching said data base for said characterization data, responsive to receipt of said portions of said data request signal; a review queue for storing said portions of said data request signal, in the event said searching for said characterization data is unsuccessful; retrieving means for retrieving said portions of said data request signal stored in said review queue; and creating means for creating and storing in said data base characterization data associated with said data request signal, in response to said retrieving.
Claim 54
Dependent Claim
80 words
The system of claim 46, further comprising: an advisory server coupled to said content requestor over a second communication link different from said first communication link wherein said advisory server is remote from said first content server, and wherein the data base is coupled to said first advisory server; setting means for setting said content requestor in an advisory mode wherein said content requestor communicates portions of said data request signal to first advisory server over said second communication link.
References Cited (Backward Citations)
US5347623A
Cited
US5560008A
Cited
US5263157A
Cited
US5410691A
Cited
US5408600A
Cited
US5619657A
Cited
US5561706A
Cited
US5394526A
Cited
US5706507A
Cited
US5583576A
Cited
US5572643A
Cited
USPTO Annuity & Maintenance Windows
| Annuity Stage | Window Opens | Payment Deadline | Surcharge Period Until | Estimated Fee | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3.5 Years (Year 4) | 2002-03-01 | 2002-08-31 | 2003-03-02 | $2000.00 | Window Closed / Lapsed |
| 7.5 Years (Year 8) | 2006-03-01 | 2006-08-31 | 2007-03-02 | $3760.00 | Window Closed / Lapsed |
| 11.5 Years (Year 12) | 2010-03-01 | 2010-08-31 | 2011-03-02 | $7700.00 | Window Closed / Lapsed |