US5684713A
Expired / Lapsed
US
⏱️ 0.0 years remaining
Method and apparatus for the recursive design of physical structures
Assignee: Massachusetts Institute of Technology
•
Filing: 1993-06-30
•
Granted: 1997-11-04
•
Expires: 2013-06-30
Abstract
Abstract In a method and an apparatus for automatically fabricating a physical prototype, an initial prototype is created, which need not satisfy the specified performance characteristics. An initial Jacobian matrix relates changes in the prototypes design variable physical features to changes in the prototype performance characteristics. The prototype is tested to determine the error between the specifications and the prototype performance characteristics. The initial Jacobian is applied to this error to generate a change order signal for the physical features. This change signal is input to a prototyping apparatus, preferably automatic and rapid, which physically changes the prototype. The prototype is again tested for satisfaction of the specifications. If necessary, the prototype is changed again and again. The Jacobian, can be automatically changed by comparing the change in performance from one prototype to the next prototype, with the change made in physical features and applying a recursive least squares method to recursively change the Jacobian. The prototype and the Jacobian automatically converge to accurate versions of each. An apparatus includes a prototype fabrication unit, an experimentation unit, and a design feature change calculation unit, which also includes a Jacobian adjustment unit. Systematic, automatic design of complex physical structures is accomplished, without the need for a precise initial prototype or understanding of the relationship between the physical features and the performance characteristics.
Inventors
- 👤 Haruhiko Asada
- 👤 Anton C. Pil
Bibliographic Details
Application Number
—
Jurisdiction
US
Data Source
google_patents
Last Synchronized
2026-11-02 00:20
CPC Classifications
G; G06; G06F; G06F30/00; G06F30/10; B; B33; B33Y; B33Y50/00
Claims Analysis
Total Claims: 30
Claim 1
Independent Claim
393 words
A method for the manufacture of a physical product exhibiting dynamic product characteristics L (a vector) with prototype values y (a vector) within an acceptable tolerance from specified values r (a vector) of said dynamic product characteristics L, the method comprising the steps of: a. providing an initial physical prototype, which is described by design variable physical features D (a vector) having values x (a vector), which design variable physical features D govern the values Y of said dynamic product characteristics L; b. providing an initial Jacobian set of rules J, which relates changes in the values x of said design variable physical features D to changes in the prototype values y of said dynamic product characteristics L; c. physically testing the prototype by dynamically exciting it to determine the present prototype values y and generating a signal representing said present prototype values y; d. generating a signal representing said specified values r and generating a dynamic product characteristics error signal, representing the difference, Δs (a vector), between said prototype values y and corresponding of said specified values r; e. if said difference represented by said error signal is not within said acceptable tolerance, performing the following steps repeatedly; i. applying said Jacobian set of rules to said error signal to generate a change x signal representing change amounts Δx to be made to the values x of said design variable physical features D; ii. physically changing said prototype so that the values x of said design variable physical features D change by said amounts Δx; iii. physically testing the prototype by dynamically exciting it to determine the present prototype values y and generating a signal representing said present prototype values y; iv. generating a dynamic product characteristics error signal, representing the difference, Δs, between said prototype values y and corresponding of said specified values r; and v. evaluating said difference represented by said error signal; vi. generating a prototype dynamic product characteristics difference signal, representing the difference, Δy, between said present prototype values y of said dynamic product characteristics L and the values y before the most recent change to said prototype; vii. relating said prototype dynamic product characteristics difference signal to said change x signal to determine whether said Jacobian set of rules requires alteration; and viii. if said Jacobian set of rules requires alteration, altering said Jacobian set of rules.
Claim 2
Independent Claim
393 words
A method for the manufacture of a physical product exhibiting dynamic product characteristics L (a vector) with prototype values y (a vector) within an acceptable tolerance from specified values r (a vector) of said dynamic product characteristics L, the method comprising the steps of: a. providing an initial physical prototype, which is described by design variable physical features D (a vector) having values x (a vector), which design variable physical features D govern the values Y of said dynamic product characteristics L; b. providing an initial Jacobian set of rules J, which relates changes in the values x of said design variable physical features D to changes in the prototype values y of said dynamic product characteristics L; c. physically testing the prototype by dynamically exciting it to determine the present prototype values y and generating a signal representing said present prototype values y; d. generating a signal representing said specified values r and generating a dynamic product characteristics error signal, representing the difference, Δs (a vector), between said prototype values y and corresponding of said specified values r; e. if said difference represented by said error signal is not within said acceptable tolerance, performing the following steps repeatedly; i. applying said Jacobian set of rules to said error signal to generate a change x signal representing change amounts Δx to be made to the values x of said design variable physical features D; ii. physically changing said prototype so that the values x of said design variable physical features D change by said amounts Δx; iii. physically testing the prototype by dynamically exciting it to determine the present prototype values y and generating a signal representing said present prototype values y; iv. generating a dynamic product characteristics error signal, representing the difference, Δs, between said prototype values y and corresponding of said specified values r; and v. evaluating said difference represented by said error signal; vi. generating a prototype dynamic product characteristics difference signal, representing the difference, Δy, between said present prototype values y of said dynamic product characteristics L and the values y before the most recent change to said prototype; vii. relating said prototype dynamic product characteristics difference signal to said change x signal to determine whether said Jacobian set of rules requires alteration; and viii. if said Jacobian set of rules requires alteration, altering said Jacobian set of rules.
Claim 3
Dependent Claim
37 words
The method of claim 1, further comprising the step of providing an automatic signal processing means for coordinating the steps of physically testing the prototype, generating said dynamic product characteristics error signal, and performing said repeated steps.
Claim 4
Dependent Claim
29 words
The method of claim 1, wherein said initial prototype has prototype values y that are outside of said acceptable tolerance from said specified values r of said product characteristics.
Claim 5
Dependent Claim
12 words
The method of claim 1, said changing step comprising photo polymer shaping.
Claim 6
Dependent Claim
11 words
The method of claim 1, said changing step comprising 3-D printing.
Claim 7
Dependent Claim
17 words
The method of claim 1, said changing step comprising the step of adding material to said prototype.
Claim 8
Dependent Claim
21 words
The method of claim 1, wherein said step of changing said prototype comprises the step of removing material from said prototype.
Claim 9
Dependent Claim
20 words
The method of claim 1, wherein said step of changing said prototype comprises the step of changing its surface characteristics.
Claim 10
Independent Claim
191 words
An apparatus for automatically manufacturing a physical article, exhibiting dynamic product characteristics L (a vector) with prototype values y (a vector) within an acceptable tolerance from specified values r (a vector) of said dynamic product characteristics L, said article described by design variable physical features D (a vector) having values x (a vector), which design variable physical features D govern the values y of said dynamic product characteristics L, said apparatus comprising: a. means for physically, dynamically exciting a physical prototype and means for measuring the dynamic product characteristic values y of said dynamically excited physical prototype; b. means for comparing said measured dynamic prototype characteristic values y to the specified values r to generate a dynamic product characteristics error signal Δs; c. means for applying a Jacobian set of rules, which relates changes in the values y of dynamic product characteristics L to changes in the values x of design features, to said dynamic product characteristics error signal Δs, to generate a change x signal; d. means for making physical changes to said prototype based on said change x signal; and e. means for adjusting said Jacobian set of rules.
Claim 11
Independent Claim
191 words
An apparatus for automatically manufacturing a physical article, exhibiting dynamic product characteristics L (a vector) with prototype values y (a vector) within an acceptable tolerance from specified values r (a vector) of said dynamic product characteristics L, said article described by design variable physical features D (a vector) having values x (a vector), which design variable physical features D govern the values y of said dynamic product characteristics L, said apparatus comprising: a. means for physically, dynamically exciting a physical prototype and means for measuring the dynamic product characteristic values y of said dynamically excited physical prototype; b. means for comparing said measured dynamic prototype characteristic values y to the specified values r to generate a dynamic product characteristics error signal Δs; c. means for applying a Jacobian set of rules, which relates changes in the values y of dynamic product characteristics L to changes in the values x of design features, to said dynamic product characteristics error signal Δs, to generate a change x signal; d. means for making physical changes to said prototype based on said change x signal; and e. means for adjusting said Jacobian set of rules.
Claim 12
Dependent Claim
82 words
The apparatus of claim 9, said means for adjusting said Jacobian comprising: a. means for comparing the dynamic product characteristic values y for a first version of a prototype, to the dynamic product characteristic values y for a second version of said prototype, to generate a prototype dynamic characteristics product difference signal; b. means for relating said change x signal to said prototype dynamic product characteristics difference signal; and c. means for using said relation to change said Jacobian set of rules.
Claim 13
Dependent Claim
34 words
The apparatus of claim 9, said means for making physical changes comprising an automatic means for taking as an input an electromechanical signal and generating as an output a physical change to said prototype.
Claim 14
Dependent Claim
15 words
The apparatus of claim 9, said means for applying said Jacobian comprising a signal processor.
Claim 15
Dependent Claim
15 words
The apparatus of claim 12, said signal processor comprising a programmed general purpose digital computer.
Claim 16
Dependent Claim
17 words
The apparatus of claim 10, said means for relating said change x signal comprising a signal processor.
Claim 17
Dependent Claim
18 words
The apparatus of claim 11 said means for making physical changes comprising means for applying a photosetting plastic.
Claim 18
Dependent Claim
21 words
The apparatus of claim 15, said means for making physical changes further comprising means for pumping said photosetting plastic under pressure.
Claim 19
Independent Claim
163 words
A method for automatically manufacturing a physical article, exhibiting dynamic product characteristics L (a vector) with prototype values y (a vector) within an acceptable tolerance from specified values r (a vector) of said dynamic product characteristics L, said article described by design variable physical features D (a vector) having values x (a vector), said method comprising the steps of: a. physically, dynamically exciting a physical prototype; b. measuring the values y of said dynamically excited physical prototype; c. comparing said values y to the specified values r to generate a dynamic product characteristics error signal Δs; d. applying a Jacobian set of rules to said dynamic product characteristics error signal, Δs, to generate a change x signal to change the values x of design features; e. physically changing said prototype based on said change x signal; f. evaluating whether said Jacobian set of rules should be changed; and g. changing said Jacobian set of rules if said evaluation indicates change to be appropriate.
Claim 20
Independent Claim
163 words
A method for automatically manufacturing a physical article, exhibiting dynamic product characteristics L (a vector) with prototype values y (a vector) within an acceptable tolerance from specified values r (a vector) of said dynamic product characteristics L, said article described by design variable physical features D (a vector) having values x (a vector), said method comprising the steps of: a. physically, dynamically exciting a physical prototype; b. measuring the values y of said dynamically excited physical prototype; c. comparing said values y to the specified values r to generate a dynamic product characteristics error signal Δs; d. applying a Jacobian set of rules to said dynamic product characteristics error signal, Δs, to generate a change x signal to change the values x of design features; e. physically changing said prototype based on said change x signal; f. evaluating whether said Jacobian set of rules should be changed; and g. changing said Jacobian set of rules if said evaluation indicates change to be appropriate.
Claim 21
Dependent Claim
95 words
The method of claim 17, further comprising the step of conducting the following steps until said dynamic product characteristics error signal, Δs, is within said accepted tolerance: a. physically, dynamically exciting said physical prototype and measuring the values y of said physical prototype; b. comparing said values y to the specified values r to generate a dynamic product characteristics error signal Δs; c. applying said Jacobian set of rules to said dynamic product characteristics error signal, Δs, to generate a change x signal; and d. physically changing said prototype based on said change x signal.
Claim 22
Dependent Claim
62 words
The method of claim 18, wherein said step of evaluating whether said Jacobian set of rules should be changed is based on a comparison of said change x signal and the difference between the dynamic product characteristics y of a prototype and the dynamic product characteristics of said prototype immediately before said most recent step of physically changing said prototype was conducted.
Claim 23
Independent Claim
102 words
A method for the manufacture of a physical product comprising the steps of: a. providing an initial prototype; b. physically, dynamically exciting said product and testing said prototype for satisfaction of specified dynamic product characteristics; c. using the results of said testing step to automatically generate a set of changes to be made to features of the structure of said prototype; d. automatically applying said set of feature changes to physically change the structure of said prototype using a rapid prototyping method; and e. repeating said testing, change generating and prototype changing steps until said prototype satisfies said specified dynamic product characteristics.
Claim 24
Independent Claim
102 words
A method for the manufacture of a physical product comprising the steps of: a. providing an initial prototype; b. physically, dynamically exciting said product and testing said prototype for satisfaction of specified dynamic product characteristics; c. using the results of said testing step to automatically generate a set of changes to be made to features of the structure of said prototype; d. automatically applying said set of feature changes to physically change the structure of said prototype using a rapid prototyping method; and e. repeating said testing, change generating and prototype changing steps until said prototype satisfies said specified dynamic product characteristics.
Claim 25
Dependent Claim
60 words
The apparatus of claim 9, said means for adjusting said Jacobian set of rules comprising an automatic means for taking as an input, signals representing said Jacobian set of rules, said change x signal and the dynamic product characteristic values y for two successive instances of said changing prototype, and generating as an output a new Jacobian set of rules.
Claim 26
Independent Claim
332 words
A method for the manufacture of a physical product exhibiting dynamic product characteristics with prototype values within an acceptable tolerance from specified values of said dynamic product characteristics, the method comprising the steps of: a. providing an initial physical prototype, which is described by design variable physical features that govern the values of said dynamic product characteristics; b. providing an initial Jacobian set of rules J, which relates changes in the values of said design variable physical features to changes in the prototype dynamic product characteristic values; c. physically, dynamically exciting said prototype and testing the prototype and generating a signal representing said prototype dynamic product characteristic values; d. generating a signal representing said specified values and generating a dynamic product characteristics error signal, representing the difference between said prototype values and corresponding of said specified values; e. if said difference represented by said dynamic product characteristics error signal is not within said acceptable tolerance, performing the following steps repeatedly; i. applying said Jacobian set of rules to said error signal to generate a change signal representing change amounts to be made to the values of said design variable physical features; ii. physically changing said prototype so that the values of said design variable physical features change by said change amounts; iii. physically, dynamically exciting and testing the prototype to determine the present prototype values and generating a signal representing said present prototype values; iv. generating a dynamic product characteristics error signal, representing the difference between said prototype values and corresponding of said specified values; v. evaluating said difference represented by said error signal; vi. generating a prototype characteristics difference signal, representing the difference between said present prototype values of said dynamic product characteristics and the values before the most recent change to said prototype; vii. relating said prototype characteristics difference signal to said change signal to determine whether said Jacobian set of rules requires alteration; and viii. if said Jacobian set of rules requires alteration, altering said Jacobian set of rules.
Claim 27
Independent Claim
332 words
A method for the manufacture of a physical product exhibiting dynamic product characteristics with prototype values within an acceptable tolerance from specified values of said dynamic product characteristics, the method comprising the steps of: a. providing an initial physical prototype, which is described by design variable physical features that govern the values of said dynamic product characteristics; b. providing an initial Jacobian set of rules J, which relates changes in the values of said design variable physical features to changes in the prototype dynamic product characteristic values; c. physically, dynamically exciting said prototype and testing the prototype and generating a signal representing said prototype dynamic product characteristic values; d. generating a signal representing said specified values and generating a dynamic product characteristics error signal, representing the difference between said prototype values and corresponding of said specified values; e. if said difference represented by said dynamic product characteristics error signal is not within said acceptable tolerance, performing the following steps repeatedly; i. applying said Jacobian set of rules to said error signal to generate a change signal representing change amounts to be made to the values of said design variable physical features; ii. physically changing said prototype so that the values of said design variable physical features change by said change amounts; iii. physically, dynamically exciting and testing the prototype to determine the present prototype values and generating a signal representing said present prototype values; iv. generating a dynamic product characteristics error signal, representing the difference between said prototype values and corresponding of said specified values; v. evaluating said difference represented by said error signal; vi. generating a prototype characteristics difference signal, representing the difference between said present prototype values of said dynamic product characteristics and the values before the most recent change to said prototype; vii. relating said prototype characteristics difference signal to said change signal to determine whether said Jacobian set of rules requires alteration; and viii. if said Jacobian set of rules requires alteration, altering said Jacobian set of rules.
Claim 28
Independent Claim
150 words
An apparatus for automatically manufacturing a physical article, exhibiting dynamic product characteristics having prototype values within an acceptable tolerance from specified values of said dynamic product characteristics, said article described by design variable physical features, that govern the values of said dynamic characteristics said apparatus comprising: a. means for physically, dynamically exciting a physical prototype and means for measuring the dynamic product characteristic values of said physical prototype; b. means for comparing said dynamic prototype characteristic values to the specified values to generate a dynamic product characteristics error signal; c. means for applying a Jacobian set of rules, which relates changes in the values of dynamic product characteristics to changes in the values of design features, to said dynamic product characteristics error signal, to generate a change signal; d. means for physically changing said prototype based on said change signal; and e. means for adjusting said Jacobian set of rules.
Claim 29
Independent Claim
150 words
An apparatus for automatically manufacturing a physical article, exhibiting dynamic product characteristics having prototype values within an acceptable tolerance from specified values of said dynamic product characteristics, said article described by design variable physical features, that govern the values of said dynamic characteristics said apparatus comprising: a. means for physically, dynamically exciting a physical prototype and means for measuring the dynamic product characteristic values of said physical prototype; b. means for comparing said dynamic prototype characteristic values to the specified values to generate a dynamic product characteristics error signal; c. means for applying a Jacobian set of rules, which relates changes in the values of dynamic product characteristics to changes in the values of design features, to said dynamic product characteristics error signal, to generate a change signal; d. means for physically changing said prototype based on said change signal; and e. means for adjusting said Jacobian set of rules.
Claim 30
Dependent Claim
83 words
The apparatus of claim 9, said means for adjusting said Jacobian set of rules comprising: a. means for comparing the dynamic product characteristic values for a first version of a prototype, to the dynamic product characteristic values for a second version of a prototype, to generate a prototype dynamic product characteristics difference signal; b. means for relating said change x signal to said prototype dynamic product characteristics difference signal; and c. means for using said relation to change said Jacobian set of rules.
References Cited (Backward Citations)
USPTO Annuity & Maintenance Windows
| Annuity Stage | Window Opens | Payment Deadline | Surcharge Period Until | Estimated Fee | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3.5 Years (Year 4) | 2000-11-03 | 2001-05-05 | 2001-11-04 | $2000.00 | Window Closed / Lapsed |
| 7.5 Years (Year 8) | 2004-11-03 | 2005-05-05 | 2005-11-04 | $3760.00 | Window Closed / Lapsed |
| 11.5 Years (Year 12) | 2008-11-03 | 2009-05-05 | 2009-11-04 | $7700.00 | Window Closed / Lapsed |