Method and apparatus for clone detection in a communication system

Claim 3

The method of claim 1 further comprising the step of: monitoring subscriber activity for predetermined activity indicative of an unauthorized subscriber; and generating the message in response to an occurrence of the predetermined activity.

Claim 4

The method of claim 1 wherein the identifier of each subscriber is a mobile identification number (MIN), and the step of transmitting a message further comprises transmitting a paging command including a first MIN.

Claim 5

The method of claim 1 wherein the at least one base station comprises plural base stations, the communication system includes a processor coupled to the base stations, the step of transmitting further comprises transmitting the message from each of the base stations, each response is received by a receiving base station of the plural base stations, and the step of storing and determining further comprises forwarding each response from the receiving base station to the processor along with a receiving base station identifier, storing each response and receiving base station identifier for a predetermined period in the processor, and comparing the receiving base station identifiers to determine whether an unauthorized subscriber is using the first identifier.

Claim 6

The method of claim 4 wherein the step of storing and determining further comprises storing an associated time at which each response and associated receiving base station identifier is received and comparing all the stored times and associated receiving base station identifiers to determine whether more than one subscriber is using the first identifier.

Claim 7

The method of claim 1 further comprising the step of generating the message on a random basis from a subscriber list.

Claim 8

The method of claim 1 wherein plural messages are transmitted, and the step of storing and determining includes storing each response to the plural messages and determining if an unauthorized subscriber is using the first identifier from the stored responses to the plural messages.

Claim 9

A controller for use in a communication system having plural base stations coupled to the controller for communication with plural subscribers each having an identifier, comprising: means for generating a message including a first identifier of an authorized subscriber for for transmission by the plural base stations; means for receiving and storing a response to the message from each subscriber using the first identifier; and means, coupled to the means for receiving and storing, for determining if an unauthorized subscriber is using the first identifier based on the number of stored responses to the message from different subscribers all using the first identifier.

Claim 10

A controller for use in a communication system having plural base stations coupled to the controller for communication with plural subscribers each having an identifier, comprising: means for generating a message including a first identifier of an authorized subscriber for for transmission by the plural base stations; means for receiving and storing a response to the message from each subscriber using the first identifier; and means, coupled to the means for receiving and storing, for determining if an unauthorized subscriber is using the first identifier based on the number of stored responses to the message from different subscribers all using the first identifier.

Claim 11

The controller of claim 8 further comprising: means, coupled to the means for generating, for monitoring subscriber activity for predetermined activity indicative of an unauthorized subscriber using the first identifier and, in response to an occurrence of the predetermined activity, controlling the means for generating to generate the message.

Claim 12

The controller of claim 8 wherein the identifier of each subscriber is a mobile identification number (MIN), and the means for generating a message is further adapted for generating a paging command including a first MIN.

Claim 13

The controller of claim 8 wherein the means for receiving is further adapted for receiving each response along with an associated receiving base station identifier, which identifies a base station receiving the response from a subscriber, and storing each response and receiving base station identifier for a predetermined period, and the means for determining is further adapted for comparing the stored responses and receiving base station identifiers to determine whether an unauthorized subscriber is using the first identifier.

Claim 14

A communication system having plural base stations for communication with plural subscribers each having an identifier, comprising: a message generator operable for generating a message including a first identifier of an authorized subscriber and forwarding the message to the plural base stations for transmission over a paging channel; a memory, coupled to the plural base stations, operable for receiving and storing a response to the message from each subscriber using the first identifier; and a processor, coupled to the memory, operable for determining if an unauthorized subscriber is using the first identifier from the number of stored responses to the message from different subscribers all using the first identifier.

Claim 15

A communication system having plural base stations for communication with plural subscribers each having an identifier, comprising: a message generator operable for generating a message including a first identifier of an authorized subscriber and forwarding the message to the plural base stations for transmission over a paging channel; a memory, coupled to the plural base stations, operable for receiving and storing a response to the message from each subscriber using the first identifier; and a processor, coupled to the memory, operable for determining if an unauthorized subscriber is using the first identifier from the number of stored responses to the message from different subscribers all using the first identifier.

Claim 16

The communication system of claim 12 further comprising an operator notifier device coupled to the processor and operable for alerting a system operator when the processor determines that an unauthorized subscriber is using the first identifier.